Over at
Smart Bitches, Trashy Books there was a recent post on Flawed Heroines in which an article was linked from
The Guardian on Top Ten Flawed Romanitc Heroines. Flawed as is not shiny perfect, has problems, etc.
They listed:
1. Beatrice from Much Ado About Nothing
2. Prudence Merridew from the Perfect Rake
3. Ayla from Clan of the Cave Bear
4. Lucinda Leplastier from Oscar and Lucinda.
5. Dorothy Brooke from Middlemarch.
6. Harriet Vane in Gaudy Night.
7. Lisa Palmer from What Was Lost.
8. Christabel LaMotte and Maud Bailey from Possession.
9. Miss Haversham from Great Expectations.
10.Esther Evans in Welsh Girl.
Ok....some I agree with, some I've never heard of, some SHOULD NOT BE ON THAT LIST FOR BEING TOTAL CRO MAGNUM MARY SUES. ::coughcoughaylacoughcough::
If I had to make a 10 list, in no particular order it would probably be like-
1. Beatrice from Much Ado About Nothing
2. Elizabeth Bennett from Pride & Prejudice
3. Jaenelle Angelline from Black Jewels Series
4. Emma Woodhouse from Emma
5. Surreal SaDiablo from Black Jewels Series
6. Sophie Hatter from Howl's Moving Castle
7. Regeane from The Silver Wolf
8. Helen Rossi from The Historian
9. Ophelia from Hamlet
10. Katherine of Aragon from the Constant Princess
Ok. I have to make a small note on #10. I really really did
not like that Phillippa Gregory took the stance that Katherine of Aragon lied about consumating her first marriage (to Prince Arthur). It's hard for me to totally like her Tudor books in general in terms of their accuracy history-wise. Anyway. Aside from being irked by that fictional stance on the debated question, I did like that Katherine had a good deal of backbone and such. Most people focus on Anne Boleyn for fictional fodder, so I appreciate when Katherine gets a spotlight.
So who would you guys list as favorite flawed heroines?